Turning Friends with Benefits into a Relationship? Sure, but Only with Olives in Hand!

Kyle and I were sitting by the Hudson with beer and wine, talking about how we were going to turn our friends with benefits into a relationship. How WE were going to turn our friends with benefits into a relationship. Imagine that! For other people it's easy to say. Out come phrases like "You just have to talk about it!" Just talk about it. If only it were that simple. Kyle and I have been friends for years. Kyle brought me chocolate and pizza when I had heartbreak, and in return I went with him to his sister's wedding so he wouldn't have to explain to his nosy relatives yet again why he's still not married at 32. And now we were actually talking. We talked about how to make a friends with benefits arrangement into a relationship. We were both scared. Scared of losing our best friend. Scared that the next time heartbreak hits, nobody will bring chocolate. And scared of being torn apart alive by the relatives' questions at the next wedding.
Turning friends with benefits into a relationship is possible
The risk in trying to turn friends with benefits into a relationship is that you don't gain a partner for life, you lose your best friend. Who would we have left to provide running commentary on the couples we watch in public? The "plus" in our friendship was the cuddling during movies, whenever neither of us was seeing anyone. I had often wondered whether it might be worth a try to turn our friends with benefits into a relationship, but Kyle was a grump in the morning and I wasn't.
Turning friends with benefits into a relationship has its pitfalls
He loved olives and I hated them. Under those circumstances, trying to turn our friends with benefits into a relationship was doomed from the start anyway. On the day Kyle and I sat by the river, he had woken me early in the morning with coffee in hand to head out on a bike ride. That was about as likely as me ordering extra olives at the Italian place. But there we were, sitting by the river. While I sipped my wine and stared into space, my eyes fell on my hands holding olives that I'd been snacking on. I looked at my hands and then at Kyle, who had gotten me up early. The former morning grump sat next to me smiling, and I could unbelievably feel that I had not only learned to love olives, but him too. "Kyle?" "Yeah, what?" "We're not friends, are we?" "Of course not!" he said, grinning happily in my face. We had turned our friends with benefits into a relationship, and I only noticed when I was munching on green olives. "So, shall we turn our friends with benefits into a relationship?" Then he kissed me. The phrases echoed in my ears. It's true, you have to talk, but above all you have to feel.